tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5744452068093024037.post3738585676153596435..comments2023-09-21T11:00:46.058-05:00Comments on Princess Tradescantia: Why I sign reviews.Anonymoushttp://www.blogger.com/profile/17377882709481549196noreply@blogger.comBlogger2125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5744452068093024037.post-51382124968814529482016-01-22T11:25:59.711-06:002016-01-22T11:25:59.711-06:00At the end of the comments to the author, I simply...At the end of the comments to the author, I simply include my name, affiliation, and email address. Oddly enough, I find that signing my reviews actually helps combat imposter syndrome, and again, can offer important context to the author as they interpret the review. FWIW, I think many grad students are far more critical of articles than more senior scientists (sometimes because they feel like they need to prove or justify their comments). Finally, just remember: if an editor feels comfortable asking you to review, then you should accept that your opinions are worth something!Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/17377882709481549196noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5744452068093024037.post-5242566171038291202016-01-20T10:44:57.319-06:002016-01-20T10:44:57.319-06:00How do you actually sign it? Leave your name at th...How do you actually sign it? Leave your name at the bottom of the word doc? I feel like imposter syndrome will be tough to overcome with signing reviews for me, especially while still a grad student. At least in the few opinion articles I read recently on this topic there is definitely a negative view of grad students reviewing papers.Dan Symondsnoreply@blogger.com